Knowledge Base Article

The Final Rule for the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement (CJR) Model was released on November 16, 2015 and published in the Federal Register on November 24, 2015. Unlike the proposed January 1st start date, the final rule start date is April 1, 2016 and is most definitely not an April Fool’s Day Joke. The model will include five (5) Performance Periods that will run through December 31, 2020. CMS has indicated that through an impact analysis they “expect the CJR model to result in savings to Medicare of $343 million over the 5 performance years of the model.”

Participating hospitals need to familiarize themselves with several new terms specific to the CJR Model as provided in Table 1.

Table 1: Key CJR Model Terms and Acronyms

‍CJR Model: Key Aspects

• For the first time, hospitals in selected MSAs are required to participate. CMS indicates that they “have designed the CJR model to require participation by hospitals in order to avoid the selection bias inherent to any model in which providers may choose whether to participate. Such a design will allow for testing of how a variety of hospitals will fare under an episode payment approach, leading to a more robust evaluation of the model's effect on all types of hospitals.”

• Eligible beneficiaries who elect to receive care at these hospitals will automatically be included in the model. Patients cannot opt out of this model.

• Participant hospitals will be required to supply beneficiaries with written information regarding the design and implications of this model as well as their rights under Medicare, including their right to use their provider of choice.

• Unlike the Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) and Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) 30 Day Readmission Measure, this model will include LEJR procedures that result from hip fracture treatment rather than limiting the model conditions to only elective THA and TKA.

• CMS finalized the inclusion of any lower extremity joint procedure that results in discharge from MS-DRG 469 or 470, including ankle replacement; lower leg, ankle, and thigh reattachment; and hip resurfacing procedures. CSM acknowledges that while this volume of patients is likely to be small at any one hospital, these beneficiaries may also benefit from care redesign resulting in improved care coordination and quality that are goals of this model.

Payment

• During the performance years CMS will continue paying hospitals and other providers and suppliers according to the usual Medicare FFS payment systems.

• The Repayment requirement will not begin until Performance Year 2 (Episodes that end between January 1, 2017, and December 31, 2017).

• After the completion of a performance year, the Medicare claims payments for services furnished to the beneficiary during the episode, based on claims data, will be combined to calculate an actual episode payment. The amount of this calculation, if positive, will be paid to the participant hospital. This payment will be called a reconciliation payment. If negative Medicare will require repayment of the difference between the actual episode payments and the CJR target price from a participant hospital if the CJR target price is exceeded.

• CMS will limit how much a hospital can gain or lose based on its actual episode payments relative to target prices.

Payment and Pricing: Link to Quality

Hospitals will be assigned a composite quality score annually based on their performance and improvement on the following 2 quality measures:

1. Hospital Level Risk Standardized Complication Rate (RSCR) Following Elective Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) and/or Total Knee Arthroplasty (TAK) measure (NQF #1550); and
2. Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) Survey measure (NQF #0166)

CMS intends to publicly report this information on the Hospital Compare website. Participating hospitals who successfully submit voluntary THA/TKA patient-reported outcomes and limited risk variable data will receive additional points for their composite quality score.

Program Waivers

“CMS finalized the proposal, without modification, that waivers of Medicare program rules would apply to the care of beneficiaries who are in CJR model episodes at the time the service is furnished to the beneficiary under the waiver, even if the episode is later canceled. This policy would include circumstances where a beneficiary's care is ultimately excluded from the CJR model due to a change in the beneficiary's coverage during the episode.”

CMS proposed and finalized three specific waivers of Medicare Program Rules. “The purpose of such flexibilities would be to increase LEJR episode quality and decrease episode spending or internal costs or both of providers and suppliers that results in better, more coordinated care for beneficiaries and improved financial efficiencies for Medicare, providers, and beneficiaries.”

• Home Visits Waiver
  CMS finalized their proposal, “without modification, to waive the "incident to" direct physician supervision requirement set forth at § 410.26(b)(5), to allow a CJR beneficiary who does not qualify for home health services to receive up to 9 post-discharge visits in his or her home or place of residence any time during the episode following discharge from an anchor hospitalization.”

• Billing and Payment for Telehealth Services Waiver
  CMS finalized without modification to waive the geographic site requirement and the originating site requirement to permit telehealth visits to originate in the beneficiary’s home or place of residence. Under this waiver, telehealth could not be a substitute for in-person home health services paid under the home health prospective payment system. Services must be furnished in accordance with all other Medicare coverage and payment criteria and the facility fee paid by Medicare to an originating site would be waived if the service was originated in the beneficiary’s home.

• Skilled Nursing Facility (SNF) Waiver
  Beginning in performance year 2, the CJR model waives the SNF 3-day rule for coverage of a SNF stay following the anchor hospitalization. A condition to using this waiver is that the beneficiary must be transferred to SNFs rated 3-stars or higher for at least 7 of the previous 12 months on the CMS Nursing Home Compare website. CMS will post the list of qualified SNFs quarterly to the CMS website.

Beneficiary Choice and Beneficiary Notification

CMS finalized the proposal to require that participant hospitals notify beneficiaries of the requirements surrounding the model at the point of admission to the hospital. Additional detail to the content, timing and form of the notification specified in the final rule includes:

• Participant hospitals will be required to provide beneficiaries on admission with a general notice of the existence of the model and of certain beneficiary rights.

• “Participant hospitals must require as a condition of any sharing arrangement that the collaborators must notify beneficiaries of the existence of a sharing arrangement. We are modifying our regulations to specify that, in the case of physicians, this notification must occur at the point of the decision to proceed to surgery, or, in the case of other collaborators, prior to the furnishing of the first service provided by the collaborator that is related to the joint replacement.”

• As part of discharge planning, participant hospitals “must inform beneficiaries of all Medicare participating PAC providers/suppliers in an area but may identify those providers/suppliers that the hospital considers to be preferred…..the participant hospital must also as part of this specific second notice inform the beneficiary of providers/suppliers with whom a sharing arrangement exists.”

• Participant hospitals will be required to reference the most recently published CMS list of SNFs which qualify for the waiver of the 3-day rule.

Participant hospitals have from today until March 31, 2016 to plan for an April 1st, 2016 implementation date of this model. MMP strongly encourages participant hospitals to not only read the Final Rule but become very familiar with the information available on the CJR Web page.