Knowledge Base Article

Included in the basic format for National Coverage Determinations (NCDs) are Nationally Covered Indications and Nationally Non-Covered Indications sections. In general, NCDs are created to outline covered indications. However, there are NCDs specifically detailing that a service is non-covered such as:  

• NCD 280.2 White Cane for Use by a Blind Person,
• NCD 30.5 Transcendental Meditation, and
• NCD 30.3 Acupuncture.

Fortunately, for Medicare beneficiaries, with the January 21, 2020 release of Final Decision Memo (CAG-00452N), acupuncture for chronic low back pain (cLBP) is now a viable treatment option. 

Acupuncture NCD Timeline

NCD 30.3 Acupuncture

CMS initially issued a National Non-coverage Determination for Acupuncture (NCD 30.3) in May 1980. This non-coverage determination indicates that “although acupuncture has been used for thousands of years in China and for decades in parts of Europe...Medicare reimbursement for acupuncture, as an anesthetic or as an analgesic or for other therapeutic purposes, may not be made.”

Since the initial acupuncture NCD, in 2004, CMS concluded there was no convincing evidence for the use of acupuncture for pain relief in patients with fibromyalgia or patients with osteoarthritis and published two additional NCDs for non-coverage of acupuncture:

• NCD 30.3.1 – Acupuncture for Fibromyalgia, and
• NCD 30.3.2 – Acupuncture for Osteoarthritis.

CMS Proposes to Cover Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain

In a July 15, 2019 Press Release, CMS announced their proposal to cover acupuncture for cLBP as a potential alternative to opioid use, while data is collected on patient outcomes. HHS Secretary Alex Azar noted, “Defeating our country’s epidemic of opioid addiction requires identifying all possible ways to treat the very real problem of chronic pain, and this proposal would provide patients with new options while expanding our scientific understanding of alternative approaches to pain.”

January 21, 2020: CMS Releases Final Decision Memo for Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain (CAG-00452N)

CMS indicated in a related Press Release they had “conducted evidence reviews and examined coverage policies of private payers to inform today’s decision.”

NCD 30.3.3 Acupuncture for Medicare Beneficiaries with cLBP

What is covered?

Up to 12 visits in 90 days are covered for Medicare beneficiaries under the following circumstances:

• For the purpose of this decision, chronic low back pain (cLBP) is defined as:
• Lasting 12 weeks or longer;
• nonspecific, in that it has no identifiable systemic cause (i.e., not associated with metastatic, inflammatory, infectious, etc. disease);
• not associated with surgery; and
• not associated with pregnancy.

• An additional eight sessions will be covered for those patients demonstrating an improvement. No more than 20 acupuncture treatments may be administered annually.
• Treatment must be discontinued if the patient is not improving or is regressing.

What is Non-Covered?

Nationally Non-Covered Indications: “All types of acupuncture including dry needling for any condition other than cLBP are non-covered by Medicare.”

Who Can Furnish Acupuncture for Medicare Fee-for-Service Population?  

• Physicians (as defined in 1861(r)(1)) may furnish acupuncture in accordance with applicable state requirements.
• Physician assistants, nurse practitioners/clinical nurse specialists (as identified in 1861(aa)(5)), and auxiliary personnel may furnish acupuncture if they meet all applicable state requirements and have:
• A masters or doctoral level degree in acupuncture or Oriental Medicine from a school accredited by the Accreditation Commission on Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (ACAOM); and
• Current, full, active, and unrestricted license to practice acupuncture in a State, Territory, or Commonwealth (i.e. Puerto Rico) of the United States, or District of Columbia.

Auxiliary personnel furnishing acupuncture must be under the appropriate level of supervision of a physician, physician assistant, or nurse practitioner/clinical nurse specialist required by our regulations at 42 CFR §§ 410.26 and 410.27.

Who Can Furnish Acupuncture: Comments & CMS Responses in Final Decision Memo

Comment: Several commenters suggested that acupuncture should only be performed by licensed acupuncturists and not be physicians, physician assistants, or nurse practitioners/clinical nurse specialists who would not have the specialized training a licensed acupuncturist would have.

CMS Response: The coverage criteria defined in section I of this decision memo states that physician assistants, nurse practitioners/clinical nurse specialists, and auxiliary personnel must have a masters or doctoral level degree in acupuncture or Oriental Medicine from a school accredited by the ACAOM, and language has been added to specify a current, full, active, and unrestricted license to practice acupuncture in a State, Territory, or Commonwealth (i.e. Puerto Rico) of the United States, or District of Columbia. These requirements are consistent either with the requirements of the qualification standards of private payers (which vary as discussed further below) for licensed acupuncturists who treat patients (and also the standards for VA medical centers or the requirements used to identify providers who perform acupuncture paid by the VA in the community). As noted above, licensed acupuncturists cannot directly bill Medicare for services.

Comment: One commenter requested chiropractic doctors who have completed the 100 hour acupuncture course and examination approved by the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) and the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE) be included in the list of personnel able to furnish acupuncture in the studies.

CMS Response: CMS notes that the requirements for chiropractic acupuncturists vary widely from state to state. CMS also notes Medicare covers manual manipulation of the spine if medically necessary to correct a subluxation when provided by a chiropractor (or other qualified provider). Medicare does not cover other services or tests ordered by a chiropractor, including acupuncture. However, if a chiropractor fulfills the requirements in section I of this decision memo as auxiliary personnel, they would be eligible to furnish acupuncture “incident to” a physician’s service.

What Benefit Category does Acupuncture Fall Within?

Medicare is a defined benefit program. Items or services must fall within one of the statutorily defined benefit categories outlined in the Social Security Act. According to the Decision Memo, acupuncture qualifies as:

• Incident to a physician’s professional service,
• Inpatient Hospital Services,
• Outpatient Hospital Services Incident to a Physician’s Service, and
• Physician’s Services

Consideration of Benefits and Harms

“We believe that in light of the relative safety of the procedure and the grave consequences of the opioid crisis in the United States, there is sufficient rationale to provide this nonpharmacologic treatment to appropriate beneficiaries with chronic low back pain. Several professional societies and experts (such as the American Pain Association and American College of Physicians) also supported acupuncture as a nonpharmacologic treatment option to consider.

We have reviewed coverage policies of private payers including integrated health systems. A number of other payers such as Aetna, various Blue Cross Blue Shield plans, Cigna, Kaiser Permanente, and United Healthcare provide some coverage of acupuncture for certain indications or offer advantage plans that may provide coverage. There is variation in covered indications and frequency of services.”

NCD 30.3.3 Acupuncture for cLBP

Effective for services performed on or after January 21, 2020, CMS will cover acupuncture for Medicare patients with cLBP when the Nationally Covered Indications are met and will be manualized under NCD 30.3.3, Acupuncture for cLBP.